The Chartership Forum

ISTRUCTE / SHORT EXERCISE / communication

Exercise cm-ex-16

Write setting out where matching helps and where it costs, and proposing a partial departure.

In this guide
PRACTICE PROMPT

Use this fictional setting to practise clear reasoning. It is not an assessment or institution paper.

The setting

A hospital extension where the brief requires the structural grid to match the existing building exactly.

Your task

Write setting out where matching helps and where it costs, and proposing a partial departure.

What a useful response would show

Selective compliance argued rather than wholesale acceptance or rejection.

Reflect afterwards

  1. What assumption mattered most?
  2. What would you check before using this on a real project?
  3. Could another engineer follow your recommendation?