The Chartership Forum

ISTRUCTE / Core Objectives

3. Concept Creation and Design

Develop a structural solution from a brief, considering form, grid and load paths alongside safety, carbon, durability, reuse, appearance and cost.

In this guide
LEARNING GUIDE

Use this material to examine your own work. Confirm current requirements, forms and dates with IStructE before applying.

The minimum standard is Experience for Incorporated-Member and Ability for Chartered Member. Concept Creation and Design is the only objective where the grades require different standards.

What strong and weak evidence look like

Look for

  • Two different arrangements you compared, with the reason one was chosen.
  • A sketch showing the load path, drawn by you at the time rather than reconstructed afterwards.
  • A stability strategy you set, and what would have happened without it.
  • A concept that changed because of carbon, cost or buildability, with the before and after.
  • A decision on a transfer, a movement joint or a grid that had consequences you can describe.

Watch for

  • Describing the scheme that was built without saying who chose it.
  • "The project used a reinforced-concrete frame": a fact about the project, not about you.
  • Options that differ only in member size or material, which is not a real comparison.
  • Concept work presented with no sketch of your own anywhere in the portfolio.

Portfolio items that tend to work here

Suggestions, not a required list. What matters is that the item is yours, that it is annotated, and that it demonstrates the standard rather than the subject.

Questions to ask yourself

  1. Which arrangement did I choose, and what did I reject?

    A concept with only one option in it is not a decision.

  2. Can I draw the load path for my own project, from roof to ground, without notes?

    Reviewers ask for exactly this, and it is where thin concept evidence shows.

  3. What holds it up sideways?

    Stability is the fastest way for a reviewer to find out whether you understood the scheme or inherited it.

The same objective, in different kinds of work

SettingWhat the evidence tends to look like
BuildingsSetting a grid around an awkward transfer, and choosing between flat slab and beam-and-slab on more than span alone.
BridgesSelecting a deck form and articulation, and understanding what the bearings and the abutments are being asked to do.
Existing structuresDeciding what the existing frame can be asked to carry, and where new load must go around it.

Illustrative. The objectives are written to be met in a range of ways by anyone practising as a structural engineer.

How reviewers tend to approach this objective

  • Asking you to sketch the structure and its load path, live.
  • Asking what the second scheme was, and why it lost.
  • Asking what you would change if the grid moved, or a column had to go.
  • Moving from your project to a fundamentals question about stability or robustness.

There is a bank of original practice questions in the interview question bank, filterable by objective and by grade.

Official sources

Selected publisher pages were rechecked in September 2026. Other source records were last checked in July 2026. Open the latest official document before relying on a requirement.